The Debunk for Asajj Ventress Republic Comics feat

As you all know LFL policy dictates that George Lucas has the most say of anyone in lucasfilm and is the "word of god" over all other sources. As such I have come to bring light to new information that may prove useful in constructing a more critical analysis of Garbajj Wenchress starting with evidence from George's mouth himself:



According to Lucas's version of events Anakin Skywalker got the scar slipping in the bathtub. As Lucas takes priority over all other EU sources the entire fight on Coruscant never happened. Asajj Ventress has never cut Anakin's face despite what republic comics would lead you to believe.

So the bathtub can permanently mark Anakin but Ventress couldn't. Pathetic.

This is why Chee has said that not every Lucas statement takes precedence over the C canon EU.

Edit: this is a perfectly legit argument, moderators can't move it just because they don't like it, that is an abuse of power. This stays in the star wars legends section

If you didn't want it moved, you shouldn't have named it a blatantly troll title initially.

g canon

Trolling aside, I don't think the bathtub thing was supposed to be taken seriously. If that's something that happened to Kylo or Rey then sure that'd make sense but I'd have a hard time believing it happened to Anakin.

Nah. In the comic we saw how it really happened. So George is simply wrong.

Lucas literally says it's something for the comics to explain, then jokes about him slipping in the bathtub.

Lucas wasn't joking when he said on multiple occasions that Vader was challenged by Luke, and that Maul is faster than Ben Kenobi and Vader.

The attempt to put these two different types of quotes on equal ground in terms of their authority in continuity does not work.

What if its something like GL saying Jango Fett isn't a Mandalorian? Does that immediately wipe away his comic series Open Seasons where he was depicted as a Mandalorian?

Uh, no. Lucas would simply be wrong in that case.

Azronger wrote:Uh, no. Lucas would simply be wrong in that case.

How can the creator be wrong?
BTW Lucas did actually say Jango isn't a mandalorian

Because the actual story says he is a Mandalorian.

Well Fett was adopted by Mandalorians so that could be what he's referring to.

Azronger wrote:Uh, no. Lucas would simply be wrong in that case.

@Azronger I think you missed my point. If Lucas's word is so powerful enough to retcon C-CANON statements or stories wouldn't that wipe away any story that depicts Jango as a Mandalorian from Legends canon as he has explicitly said Jango isn't a mandalorian?

SithSauce wrote:

Azronger wrote:Uh, no. Lucas would simply be wrong in that case.

@Azronger I think you missed my point. If Lucas's word is so powerful enough to retcon C-CANON statements or stories wouldn't that wipe away any story that depicts Jango as a Mandalorian from Legends canon as he has explicitly said Jango isn't a mandalorian?

 
When was that said?

@SithSauce I did not miss your point. I responded to it as suitably as I believed was necessary.

@Latham2000 Stop spamming. Removed the frivolous posts.