Suspect Insight Forums

Go down
Latham2000
Latham2000
Level One
Level One

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Tue 21 Apr - 13:36
Setting: The hypoethetical Star Wars character is in middle earth and they snatch it off Bilbo once he makes his way back to the Shire after the battle of the five armies. What happens if these guys got the ring?

1). TFU II Darth Vader.
2). RotS Count Dooku.
3). RotJ Darth Sidious.
4). SoD Darth Maul.
5). AotC Anakin Skywalker.
6). EoRotS Obi-Wan Kenobi.
7). Galen Marek.
8). RotS Mace Windu.
9). Snoke.
10). Table Darth Vader.

Go.
The Dark Apprentice
The Dark Apprentice
Level Two
Level Two

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Tue 21 Apr - 13:41
No matter what kind of willpower feats any of them have if someone as pure and strong minded as gandalf or Frodo are corrupted by the ring you bet your ass all of these people become ringwraiths and saurons new bitches
Nute_Chethray
Nute_Chethray

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 13:59
All characters turn near immideatedly and get drawn to Sauron by the Ring, getting turned there and giving him back his full power.

Maybe Kenobi sees the danger and tries to give it to someone stronger but he wouldn't last long
Latham2000
Latham2000
Level One
Level One

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 14:19
What happens to Snoke specifically?
Nute_Chethray
Nute_Chethray

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 14:28
@Latham2000 wrote:What happens to Snoke specifically?
Turns immideatedly and gets drawn to Sauron by the Ring, getting turned there and giving Sauron back his full power.
Azronger
Azronger
Moderator
Moderator

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 17:20
> Korriban wrote:No matter what kind of willpower feats any of them have if someone as pure and strong minded as gandalf or Frodo are corrupted by the ring you bet your ass all of these people become ringwraiths and saurons new bitches

Star Wars characters have resisted way more intensive hax than the One Ring.

_________________
What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Sheev_sig_3
BoD
BoD
Level Five
Level Five

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 18:50
1). TFU II Darth Vader.
2). RotS Count Dooku.
3). RotJ Darth Sidious.
4). SoD Darth Maul.
5). AotC Anakin Skywalker.

All of these fail to resist. They're either too power hungry, arrogant or greedy to resist.


6). EoRotS Obi-Wan Kenobi.

Resists. This Kenobi had already lost the woman he'd loved, his friends, his colleagues, kids he cared about, his fellow Council members, and had to fight someone he loved like a brother while conquering his own inner demons. He resists.



7). Galen Marek.

I'd say he'd resist, but it depends what stage he's at. Pre-TFU 2 Galen falls, TFU 2 SK probably just about resists.



8). RotS Mace Windu.

Doesn't fall. Mace's willpower in regards to his commitment to principles (i.e. his service to the light side) is arguably greater than anyone here, save for maybe Kenobi. 


9). Snoke.

Falls faster than a Sequel Trilogy character arc.


10). Table Darth Vader.

Falls.

Overall, only 2, maybe 3 will resist.
The lord of hunger
The lord of hunger
Level One
Level One

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 19:36
2 and 3 resist 
all other fall
Azronger
Azronger
Moderator
Moderator

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 20:57
I feel like people are applying a no-limits fallacy to the One Ring, that literally any character with selfish motives is going to be influenced even if they're orders of magnitude more powerful and willful than any character in LOTR who fell victim to the Ring.

_________________
What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Sheev_sig_3
The Dark Apprentice
The Dark Apprentice
Level Two
Level Two

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

on Thu 23 Apr - 21:48
@Azronger wrote:I feel like people are applying a no-limits fallacy to the One Ring, that literally any character with selfish motives is going to be influenced even if they're orders of magnitude more powerful and willful than any character in LOTR who fell victim to the Ring.

No, it's the fact that Gandalf himself (angel of good) considered it's corruption beyond what he could handle. I'm unconvinced people who aren't dieties like the Maiar would be able to do any better
Sponsored content

What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring? Empty Re: What if these Star Wars characters found the One Ring?

Back to top
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum