Rots game Drallig vs. Yoda

iamthatguy wrote:

And Anakin sometimes uses the DS as a Jedi such as during his fight against Dooku. Nothing has been contradicted.

All those sources describe Anakin when he's not embracing the darkside, so still contradicted.

How?

iamthatguy wrote:

How?

Wym how? I just told you: they all refer to Jedi Anakin, who isn't drawing on the darkside.  Gillard indicated Jedi lightside Anakin was an 8, therefore the supremacy quotes are incorrect since a tier 8 (Anakin) cannot be above tier 9s (Yoda, Windu)

But Jedi Anakin does draw on the DS...

KingKopecz wrote:Nope

iamthatguy wrote:

KingKopecz wrote:Nope

There's literally no way around this.  All the sources claiming Anakin is the best Jedi (most of them refer to potential btw not even actualized power) are rendered incorrect by Gillard himself since he's confirmed an 8.  Windu and Agen claiming Anakin is the strongest Jedi in the ROTS novel is just as contradictory since they haven't seen him go Zonakin, though it's ok for them to be incorrect since they're characters in the story and not OOU sources.

iamthatguy wrote:

KingKopecz wrote:Nope

I feel as if we're just going in circles now. Anakin ever since LoE has been said to be the most powerful Jedi. Gillard having LS Anakin as an 8 doesn't contradict this as when using the DS he's a 9 and he does this when he's still a Jedi.

CuckedCurry wrote:2 bastard pages of this nonsensical garbage thread. Let’s make a Serra Keto v Yoda thread while we’re at it, seeing how she manages to physically pin KFV up to a pillar

Shimrra wrote:Yoda

Jedi Anakin who is a confirmed a tier 8 by Gillard

rendering them incorrect since he's locked below tier 9. Thus the sources refer to potential power and not Anakin's actualized power

Jedi Anakin is not a tier 9 by literal definition of being a Jedi and not using the darkside

All those sources describe Anakin when he's not embracing the darkside, so still contradicted.

they all refer to Jedi Anakin, who isn't drawing on the darkside.

(most of them refer to potential btw not even actualized power)

meaning lightside Jedi Anakin, not darkside Jedi Anakin.

Anakin doesn't have the feats to suggest he's in Yoda/Sidious league

Taking 10 seconds to kill Drallig compared to Sidious butchering the B-Team (who are all superior to Drallig)

Nute_Chethray wrote:She got no more toyed with than Drallig

Vaelias wrote:

Nute_Chethray wrote:She got no more toyed with than Drallig

Vader Toys with Keto, she does not pose any threat to him throughout the whole fight, he easily kills her whilst smiling, then Drallig comes in and ragdolls Vader to where Vader only beats Drallig with a cheap shot

BreakofDawn wrote:

Vaelias wrote:

Nute_Chethray wrote:She got no more toyed with than Drallig

Vader Toys with Keto, she does not pose any threat to him throughout the whole fight, he easily kills her whilst smiling, then Drallig comes in and ragdolls Vader to where Vader only beats Drallig with a cheap shot

Doesn't look like he's toying with her.

AA3 wrote:He's also using one hand... which is completely contrary to his normal fighting style.

He isn't though the only Tier system quotes that mention Anakin say he is a 9, you could argue that that is referring to Anakin after he is turned to the Darkside but no where is Anakin ever stated to be an 8

The Tier System is purely combative ability and has nothing to do with force power whatsoever, so no

You can still be a Jedi and use the Darkside, or are you implying that Anakin when he taps into the Darkside in Episode 2 or on the invisible hand is no longer a Jedi? thats ridiculous, Mace taps into the Darkside when using Vapaad, is he no longer a Jedi for those brief moments? LOL

No lol, he is still a Jedi he is still Anakin, nothing is contradicted

Citation needed, sounds like your head canon to me

Citation Needed, Again sounds like your head canon

There is no such thing as Darkside Jedi Anakin, he taps into the Darkside from time to time, no where are the quotes indicated to exclude Anakin when he's tapping into the Darkside, that wouldn't even make sense, sounds like your head canon again

Stopping the Theta storm which Obi-wan highly doubted Yoda could do, also feats are irrelevant when Anakin is constantly stated to be the most powerful Jedi of the Era, your counter argument for that has no basis and is purely head canon, Yes Yoda has some quotes that contradict these, but that is why rough parity between the two is a generally accepted stance

How are they all superior to Drallig, Drallig is superior by almost all indicators, Especially Game Drallig who is Equal to Yoda given that he ragdolled KFV, also i dont even see your point here, in the Movie Anakin cut Drallig down instantly with one hand while choking out one of his Padawan's

But hey G- Canon is the highest level of canon and two G-Canon statements declare Anakin = Sidious
and by some indicators he is even > Sidious

AA3 wrote:He's also using one hand... which is completely contrary to his normal fighting style.