Ranking the PT Jedi

That's the weakest version.

How do the number of sources matter? Jinn can last 30 seconds against Maul, great, but Drallig's showing is better, any day. Obviously nothing is certain, and neither is Drallig>Jinn, but it looks that way.

I also don't think the number of hands makes a difference to the speed. Fighters adjust accordingly in regards to skill, and strength isn't the reason Drallig was cut down.

Fisto lasts just about as long against Sidious, and there was a dark side shroud. The feat is just really shakey, and I doubt most people here are willing to use that as solid evidence.

And no, I said Jinn can fight evenly with Maul for half a minute, but he can fight through the fatigue for longer based on his performance in the movie.

Meatpants wrote:>when you have Depa and Fisto above Qui-Gon.

>When you have Kolar and Tiin above Kit Fisto.

The B-team are all about the same level really, not really well versed on the semantics. I presented that list as a rough idea to start from anyway.

Meatpants wrote:The B-team are all about the same level really, not really well versed on the semantics. I presented that list as a rough idea to start from anyway.

Fair enough, but Kolar and Tiin lack very much in feats, and do not have a lot of impressive showings.
Fisto atleast has being AOTC Obi Wan's superior in the Cestus Deception.

1: Yoda
2: Kenobi (end of ROTS)
3: JMace Windu (ROTS)
4: Jedi Dooku
5. Qui-Gon Jinn
6 Cin Drallig (mainly based on LOE hype)
7: Fisto (higher then the rest of B-team)
8: Mundi
9: Tiin
10: Kolar

Kek at KFV being below Yoda.

OT: (Without Anakin)

1.Yoda
2.Mace Windu
3.Jedi Dooku
4.Obi Wan Kenobi
5.Jorus C'baoth
6.Jinn
7.Drallig
8.Mundi
9.Fisto
10.Tiin

Excluding Anakin?

1. Yoda
2. Mace Windu
3/4. Jedi Dooku/Obi-Wan Kenobi
5. Jorus C'baoth
6. Qui-Gon Jinn
7. Ki-Adi Mundi
8/9. Plo Koon/Kit Fisto
10. Seasee Tinn or Agen Kolar

Not sure what to think of Drallig.

TheGlory wrote:Excluding Anakin?

1. Yoda
2. Mace Windu
3/4. Jedi Dooku/Obi-Wan Kenobi
5. Jorus C'baoth
6. Qui-Gon Jinn
7. Ki-Adi Mundi
8/9. Plo Koon/Kit Fisto
10. Seasee Tinn or Agen Kolar

Not sure what to think of Drallig.  

Who are u on CV btw?

SithSauce wrote:

TheGlory wrote:Excluding Anakin?

1. Yoda
2. Mace Windu
3/4. Jedi Dooku/Obi-Wan Kenobi
5. Jorus C'baoth
6. Qui-Gon Jinn
7. Ki-Adi Mundi
8/9. Plo Koon/Kit Fisto
10. Seasee Tinn or Agen Kolar

Not sure what to think of Drallig.  

Who are u on CV btw?

Not anymore.

@theglory Were u radioactivehaggis?

SithSauce wrote:@theglory Were u radioactivehaggis?

Yoga
Face Windu
Bananakin Groundsprinter
Obi-Wan Keknobi
who cares

ILS wrote:Yoga
Face Windu
Bananakin Groundsprinter
Obi-Wan Keknobi
who cares

you have Maul above Windu and Windu above anakin

wat?

ILS wrote:wat?

I might be mistaken

But I was pretty sure you debated for Maul in a "Maul vs Windu" Battlethread, citing their shared duels with Sheev as your primary source of argumentation.

If you were serious about the rankings you gave, that means Maul > Windu > Anakin... which I consider retarded

1- Yoda
2- Windu
3- Obi-Wan
4-Jorus
4- Jedi Dooku
5- Tiin
6- Kolar
7- Fisto
8- Deepa
9- Ki-Adi-Mundi
10- Qui-Gon

1. Yoda/Kolar
2. Tiin
3. Jedi Dooku

I'm gonna revive a week-old thread because why not:

1. Yoda
2. Mace Windu
3. Obi-Wan Kenobi
4. Jedi Dooku
5. A'Sharad Hett
6. Qui-Gon Jinn
7. Yaddle
8. Ki-Adi-Mundi
9. Kit Fisto
10. Plo Koon

Not sure what to do with Drallig or C'baoth.

Why's Hett so high?

ArkhamAsylum3 wrote:Why's Hett so high?

Because he murked a mid-CW Anakin while unarmed, and fought fairly evenly with a just post-RotS Kenobi. He shouldn't be too far below RotS Kenobi overall.

SithArchaeologist wrote:

ArkhamAsylum3 wrote:Why's Hett so high?

Because he murked a mid-CW Anakin while unarmed,

Nah, it was only early TCW Anakin, since everything involving Padawan Anakin has apparently been pushed back in the timeline because TCW steamrolled in.

TheGlory wrote:

SithArchaeologist wrote:

ArkhamAsylum3 wrote:Why's Hett so high?

Because he murked a mid-CW Anakin while unarmed,

Nah, it was only early TCW Anakin, since everything involving Padawan Anakin has apparently been pushed back in the timeline because TCW steamrolled in.

Ah, right. Still, he completely murderstomped Anakin.

Kudos for picking that up. Might come back to this later.

1. Yoda
2. Kenobi
3. Mace
4. Asharad Hett
5. Jedi dooku
6. Drallig
7. Jinn
8. Sharad hett
9. Fisto
10. rest of B team