AoTC obi wan vs AoTC anakin

all out fight .
takes place in petranaki arena .
who wins ?

Skywalker is more skilled, but Kenobi is more powerful.

Anakin is a better duelist and more powerful. I can see Kenobi pulling off some tricks or whatever, but not convinced he'd take a majority.

Obi-Wan.

i think obi wan> anakin in almost everything by this point, aside from martial arts based shit, so imma go with him

Anakin is holistically portrayed as better tbh.

Several lines of comparison put Kenobi superior or equal to Anakin along the Clone Wars till 21 BBY so unless his jump in power is higher than Anakin's then the more logical choice is that Obi Wan is better

The difference in the Dooku fight can easily be chalkeddown to Kenobi being even more worse off than Anakin and Anakin being enraged by some quote. Doubt he can just channel his anger effectively at this point for the majority

LOTL wrote:Several lines of comparison put Kenobi superior or equal to Anakin along the Clone Wars till 21 BBY so unless his jump in power is higher than Anakin's then the more logical choice is that Obi Wan is better

Such as?

DC77 (Reborn) wrote:

LOTL wrote:Several lines of comparison put Kenobi superior or equal to Anakin along the Clone Wars till 21 BBY so unless his jump in power is higher than Anakin's then the more logical choice is that Obi Wan is better

Such as?

The TCW Junior Novel, feat comparisons side by side to their limits, the opinion of Ahsoka etc. 

Let's not stress out, I am cognizant of the fact that I have many such appointments pending. Going to make them all soon. This is just so that people can be brought to light that these things exist and the opinion on the site on Kenobi is consistent

Power isn't everything. Kenobi is the smarter more measured fighter, Anakin is the more gifted and naturally talented Jedi they both have advantages and either could conceivably take it. Anakin's performance against Ventress in the TCW movie isn't really that much worse than Kenobi's:

Spoiler:

He gained the advantage in short order despite her utilizing an unfamiliar weapon and style and knowing his style from previous encounters. She scored a Force push, but it only disarmed him because he hit the wall. So far I see no real disparity between TCW Anakin and TCW Obi-Wan. And no she did not "pin him to the wall" with a telekinetic Force grip, he's being pinned down by her advances as he is unarmed. It's a complex sentence with a clear cause and effect: Ventress is advancing on him, and in effect pinning him to the wall. That Ventress scored a Force push is good for her but it doesn't mean she would be successful all the time, shifts between evenly matched opponents happen, much like they did on Yavin IV where they both scored Force pushes.