Revan(KotOR) vs Revan(Foundry)

I’ve had some people arguing with me that’s KotOR Revan should be placed above Foundry Revan in my gauntlet order. This dispute will be settled once and for all.

KOTOR Revan has generally better feats, he ran the SF gauntlet and still had enough left in the tank to slap down Malak multiple times in a row while greatly hindered. This same Malak wielded powers "far greater" than Exar Kunt granting KOTOR Revan incredibly juicy scaling to basically everything in TOTJ (which I'm sure you're aware of).

Meanwhile, Foundry Revan's claim to fame is losing to the Act 2 Imperial Protags...

Correction: Per the story mode, he might have lost to just one of the act 2 protagonists (EW or Darth Nox).

No, the canon playthrough states that no one hero could defeat Revan alone, per Malgus himself. It's clearly a group effort.

LadyKulvax wrote:No, the canon playthrough states that no one hero could defeat Revan alone, per Malgus himself. It's clearly a group effort.

BreakofDawn wrote:Correction: Per the story mode, he might have lost to just one of the act 2 protagonists (EW or Darth Nox).

Revan fought the whole strike team canonically:

Star Wars The Old Republic official website wrote:To take the station, the Empire sends a small group of its most powerful champions to the asteroid surface to storm the base, fight their way through the army of droids and defeat the crazed Jedi once and for all.

Master of the Revanites Codex, Star Wars The Old Republic wrote:Escaping imprisonment in a mad bid to destroy the Emperor for good, he was stopped by an Imperial strike force and believed dead.

Star Wars The Old Republic Encyclopedia wrote:Revan's plot was ultimately defeated by an Imperial strike force sent to claim the Foundry for the Empire.

Spirit Revan, Star Wars The Old Republic - Shadow of Revan wrote:"When the Emperor's followers struck me down, I learned to release my attachments."

Foundry Revan by far

I’d go with Foundry Revan

Foundry. He has his memories and powers, and can use the force in balance.