Darth Tenebrous vs Starkiller

@IdrisianGraecus

Banite scaling.

You've not expanded on why this puts him above Galen.

I have nothing against Galen, but Tenebrous found Ramage’s teachings simple. His raw mastery should be vastly beyond galens.

His mastery+knowledge are definitely above Galen's, but you've not actually expanded on how this places him above Galen in a fight or why he's close to Galen in other areas (e.g. duelling, power, etc). Simply listing some of his accomplishments and stating a premise I'm already agreed with doesn't convince me he's beyond Galen.

Wins via Banite scaling imo

Tenebrous, rather easily.

EmperorCaedus wrote:Tenebrous, rather easily.

You already posted your opinion a few hours ago on the first page, everyone is aware of it. Once again, I must ask you for reasons.

he didnt have ramage's teachings, i think lol it was lost iirc.

In all seriousness, Tenebrous should take it in a great fight. He's more powerful, sure, but he's also less skilled.

Reasons?

HP, are you looking to get into an extensive debate here?

Tenebrous clowns, good fight.

Azronger wrote:HP, are you looking to get into an extensive debate here?

Nah, I want to have a quick back and forth on the subject, nothing too extensive.

Tenebrous

@NotAA3:

1. Per Chee, Maul duel is N-Canon.

The duel was created as a hypothetical what if, to answer the question of who was greater between Maul and Vader. Its canon status is irrelevant to its purpose for existing, and the outcome of the match.

2. Galen won his first fight with Vader.

By abusing Vader's cybernetic weaknesses via lightning, which is irrelevant to my comparison.

Plus, their duel happened while SK was exhausted, and Vader specifically tailored his fighting style to perfectly defend against SK.

Defer to my rebuttals in the Galen vs Luke thread for my thoughts on this subject.

@DC77 (Reborn) Not going to respond in this thread - I don't see much point in getting into another debate on what is basically the same subject (scaling over Galen via Vader), so I'll leave this thread and respond in the other one instead.

@The Apprentice Gotcha bro.