Kyle Katarn vs Qui-Gon Jinn

Katarn as of Legacy of the Force
Jinn as of The Phantom Menace

R1: Sabers
R2: All Out

BONUS: If you believe Katarn wins, Obi-Wan Kenobi (The Phantom Menace) joins Jinn against him. If you believe Jinn wins Valin Horn (Fate of the Jedi) joins Katarn against Jinn.

Katarn wins via Viun Galaan scaling. He probably loses the bonus round, though.

Katarn.

Katarn makes him his bitch via Jerec scaling.

K A T A R N

DC77 wrote:Katarn makes him his bitch via Jerec scaling.

Could you elaborate? I haven't played Dark Forces II and my knowledge on Katarn isn't all too great

What of the bonus round? Would the Katarn backers (everyone so far) support him if TPM Kenobi was added to back Jinn?

@Blade_of_Dorin [url=suspectinsight.forumotion.com/t13-ss-the-tyrannical-ten-darth-caedus-dc77-vs-darth-vader-ethanion]suspectinsight.forumotion.com/t13-ss-the-tyrannical-ten-darth-caedus-dc77-vs-darth-vader-ethanion[/url]

I can't be bothered repeating arguments so skip to post 2, section 2.

OT-Still Katarn.

DC77 wrote:@Blade_of_Dorin [url=suspectinsight.forumotion.com/t13-ss-the-tyrannical-ten-darth-caedus-dc77-vs-darth-vader-ethanion]suspectinsight.forumotion.com/t13-ss-the-tyrannical-ten-darth-caedus-dc77-vs-darth-vader-ethanion[/url]

I can't be bothered repeating arguments so skip to post 2, section 2.

OT-Still Katarn.

thx

I've yet to be convinced that Katarn was a near-equal to Caedus, and the Jerec scaling is bogus. Qui-Gon should win via his status in the Jedi order during its prime and his duels against Darth Maul.

I'm open to Katarn winning, if sufficient evidence can be brought to the table, though.

Kyle Katarn

Jinn wins by virtue of that God-awful Kyle picture.

Jinn, good fight.

Qui-Gon easily.

Kyle dies badly

Qui-Gon stomps.

I've yet to be convinced that Katarn was a near-equal to Caedus, and the Jerec scaling is bogus. Qui-Gon should win via his status in the Jedi order during its prime and his duels against Darth Maul.

I'm open to Katarn winning, if sufficient evidence can be brought to the table, though.

Qui-Gon stomps.

@Meatpants

My stance has changed in six months, updating it here.

Kyle

Cheth wrote:Kyle

Why?

MuH cAEduS TAxes!

Blade_of_Dorin wrote:

Cheth wrote:Kyle

Why?

Beating Desann, the inquisitors and dark jedi before undergoing enough growth to become the jedi battlemaster

Anoon Bondara and Sora Bulq were among the best swordsman to ever exist, and both were greatly inferior to Qui-Gon. Title doesn’t mean jack shit really. 

Additionally, Kyle didn’t beat Jerec in an actual battle, and Desann has nothing to make beating him impressive.

Meatpants wrote:Anoon Bondara and Sora Bulq were among the best swordsman to ever exist, and both were greatly inferior to Qui-Gon. Title doesn’t mean jack shit really. 

Additionally, Kyle didn’t beat Jerec in an actual battle, and Desann has nothing to make beating him impressive.

Jinn would die to Bulq don’t be silly