FE Malgus vs DD Vos

Who wins?

Malgus obliterates

Malgus casually slaps him with enough force to break his neck before Vos can do anything. DD Vos' hype is beating Dooku when he's noted to have a pretty massive advantage through his unpredictability, which goes against Dooku's rigid fencing style of fighting. Malgus doesn't have this.

BoD wrote:Malgus casually slaps him with enough force to break his neck before Vos can do anything. DD Vos' hype is beating Dooku when he's noted to have a pretty massive advantage through his unpredictability, which goes against Dooku's rigid fencing style of fighting. Malgus doesn't have this.

That's like saying Anakin only beat Dooku because of his massive advantage and mastery in Djem So which goes against Dooku's fencing style of fighting. When in actual fact Anakin is>Dooku regardless of what advantage he had.

malgus shitstomps

The Witness wrote:

BoD wrote:Malgus casually slaps him with enough force to break his neck before Vos can do anything. DD Vos' hype is beating Dooku when he's noted to have a pretty massive advantage through his unpredictability, which goes against Dooku's rigid fencing style of fighting. Malgus doesn't have this.

That's like saying Anakin only beat Dooku because of his massive advantage and mastery in Djem So which goes against Dooku's fencing style of fighting. When in actual fact Anakin is>Dooku regardless of what advantage he had.

Malgus wrecks him unless this is Rage Amped Vos

BoD wrote:Malgus casually slaps him with enough force to break his neck before Vos can do anything. DD Vos' hype is beating Dooku when he's noted to have a pretty massive advantage through his unpredictability, which goes against Dooku's rigid fencing style of fighting. Malgus doesn't have this.

Vos couldn't defeat Dooku clearly. Firstly, he was able to disarm Dooku, but Dooku rose and stomped him. Second fight was trick. They did it to trick Anakin and Kenobi. Finally, Vos just manipulated Dooku's force lightning with his lightsaber.

Malgus dies

The God Emperor wrote:

BoD wrote:Malgus casually slaps him with enough force to break his neck before Vos can do anything. DD Vos' hype is beating Dooku when he's noted to have a pretty massive advantage through his unpredictability, which goes against Dooku's rigid fencing style of fighting. Malgus doesn't have this.

Vos couldn't defeat Dooku clearly. Firstly, he was able to disarm Dooku, but Dooku rose and stomped him. Second fight was trick. They did it to trick Anakin and Kenobi. Finally, Vos just manipulated Dooku's force lightning with his lightsaber.

The thing you wrote about the second duel is just false, why are you spreading fake news? And even as far as the third duel is concerned, you sound pretty confused. Dooku tried to backstab Vos by force lightining him while he wasn't paying attention. Unfortunately for Dooku, he hit Ventress and not Vos. Then Vos proceeded to beat him. Hell, since you are making up all kind of excuses (sometimes even writing false stuff) for Dooku losing, I could just say that the reason Dooku rose and stomped him in the first duel is because, as said in the novel, Vos hesistated for a second, pondering whether to kill him or not, and that little opening allowed the count to disarm Vos as well. Did you read the novel? Or at least did you read the extracts of these fights? You can easily find them in comicvine, in the Vos' respect thread. You can also find the descriptions of his fight with Ventress and Grevious

The God Emperor wrote:Malgus wrecks him unless this is Rage Amped Vos

You are probably confusing the first and second fight, I see it happening a lot. In the first duel, Vos was rage amped because he thought Ventress had died. In the second fight where Vos defeats him (which is the fight you likely have in mind), Vos was not rage amped, as noted by Dooku himself who describes him as "calmer"

Gianfi wrote:

The God Emperor wrote:

BoD wrote:Malgus casually slaps him with enough force to break his neck before Vos can do anything. DD Vos' hype is beating Dooku when he's noted to have a pretty massive advantage through his unpredictability, which goes against Dooku's rigid fencing style of fighting. Malgus doesn't have this.

Vos couldn't defeat Dooku clearly. Firstly, he was able to disarm Dooku, but Dooku rose and stomped him. Second fight was trick. They did it to trick Anakin and Kenobi. Finally, Vos just manipulated Dooku's force lightning with his lightsaber.

The thing you wrote about the second duel is just false, why are you spreading fake news? And even as far as the third duel is concerned, you sound pretty confused. Dooku tried to backstab Vos by force lightining him while he wasn't paying attention. Unfortunately for Dooku, he hit Ventress and not Vos. Then Vos proceeded to beat him. Hell, since you are making up all kind of excuses (sometimes even writing false stuff) for Dooku losing, I could just say that the reason Dooku rose and stomped him in the first duel is because, as said in the novel, Vos hesistated for a second, pondering whether to kill him or not, and that little opening allowed the count to disarm Vos as well. Did you read the novel? Or at least did you read the extracts of these fights? You can easily find them in comicvine, in the Vos' respect thread. You can also find the descriptions of his fight with Ventress and Grevious

I read the novel. Disarming someone doesn't mean to be superior to someone. Savage disarmed Dooku but he was highly below Dooku. Vos kicked Dooku's head and Dooku stumbled in the first fight, so he was able to disarm Dooku. Vos stole Dooku's lightsaber in the second fight. Dooku was gravely injured (far more injured than Vos and Venteress) in the last fight.

The God Emperor wrote:

Gianfi wrote:

The God Emperor wrote:

BoD wrote:Malgus casually slaps him with enough force to break his neck before Vos can do anything. DD Vos' hype is beating Dooku when he's noted to have a pretty massive advantage through his unpredictability, which goes against Dooku's rigid fencing style of fighting. Malgus doesn't have this.

Vos couldn't defeat Dooku clearly. Firstly, he was able to disarm Dooku, but Dooku rose and stomped him. Second fight was trick. They did it to trick Anakin and Kenobi. Finally, Vos just manipulated Dooku's force lightning with his lightsaber.

The thing you wrote about the second duel is just false, why are you spreading fake news? And even as far as the third duel is concerned, you sound pretty confused. Dooku tried to backstab Vos by force lightining him while he wasn't paying attention. Unfortunately for Dooku, he hit Ventress and not Vos. Then Vos proceeded to beat him. Hell, since you are making up all kind of excuses (sometimes even writing false stuff) for Dooku losing, I could just say that the reason Dooku rose and stomped him in the first duel is because, as said in the novel, Vos hesistated for a second, pondering whether to kill him or not, and that little opening allowed the count to disarm Vos as well. Did you read the novel? Or at least did you read the extracts of these fights? You can easily find them in comicvine, in the Vos' respect thread. You can also find the descriptions of his fight with Ventress and Grevious

I read the novel. Disarming someone doesn't mean to be superior to someone. Savage disarmed Dooku but he was highly below Dooku. Vos kicked Dooku's head and Dooku stumbled in the first fight, so he was able to disarm Dooku. Vos stole Dooku's lightsaber in the second fight. Dooku was gravely injured (far more injured than Vos and Venteress) in the last fight.

Ok, I agree with the first fight, but I think the focus here is on the second fight. You are right, in the middle of the fight Vos used the force the take the count’s saber off his hand (which I think is already a good force feat), but later Dooku was able to retrieve it, and then they started dueling. Yeah in the third fight the count had a broken arm. As I said though, the second fight should be used to gauge Vos’s power in canon. The first fight was in the first half of the novel, before Vos became Dooku’s disciple and grew stronger. In the third fight Dooku was injured so it is kinda unfair. But imo people here are a bit sleeping on the power of Vos in the new Canon. Remember that in some cut content he was also supposed to fight Maul, so these are the people he in league with in Canon

@The God Emperor 

Vos couldn't defeat Dooku clearly. Firstly, he was able to disarm Dooku, but Dooku rose and stomped him. Second fight was trick. They did it to trick Anakin and Kenobi. Finally, Vos just manipulated Dooku's force lightning with his lightsaber.