Aayla Secura vs Qui-Gon Jinn

- Standard Rules

Jinn, I don’t care about the Aurra Sing fight.

Even split

Jinn breaks her arms.

Jinn stomps.

Aayla seduces Qui-Gon VirJinn

Aayla wins. She held her own against Vos

Jinn held his own against Maul which is way more impressive.

Aalya wins.

Jinn

Wasn’t there a quote stating that TPM Kenobi>Jinn?

jinn

qui-gon while fresh was equal to TPM maul . zabrak won due to his superior stamina .
i don´t think she could replicate such showing against maul .

Gianfi wrote:Wasn’t there a quote stating that TPM Kenobi>Jinn?

There’s one stating TPM Kenobi was “quicker” but it’s very ambiguous and up for debate honestly.

There’s no quotes saying that, and Kenobi’s performance against Maul is not a viable way to compare him with Qui-Gon.

Jinn, solidly.

There’s not a single feat that Jinn has that Aayla couldn’t replicate or even surpass

Aayla gets scaling over Caedus.

But this might not be enough to beat Jinn...

When you consider that Vos can completely stomp Aayla - himself vastly inferior to a Ventress with virtually no training - there should be no question that Qui-Gon mutilates her. Add in Jinn giving Maul a run and repeatedly stomping an unparalleled and peerless fighter like Bondara in ‘brief’ duels, and it’s not close.

TPM Kenobi beats her too.

Add in the fact that Jinn was pressed by Sing, disarmed by Xanatos and Femur, nearly killed by mooks in Cloak of Deception , and is slower than TPM Kenobi, then a reluctant Secura getting blindsided by Vos doesn’t look so bad. Come back to us when Jinn can decisively defeat Aurra Sing and match Vos tiers in sabers, Eugene

Aayla

Aayla wins via Aurra Sing scaling.

I switch my vote to Aayla

MasterCilghal wrote:I switch my vote to Aayla

Why?

Jinn.