Darth Malgus vs Darth Jadus

Both in their prime.

Malgus

Jadus had better accolades and would beat FE Malgus but gets 0.0001 shotted by new Malgus.

Malgus crushes.

Reasons for Malgus winning so easily?

They think near parity to Outlander bumps Malgus up enormously. Not realising the enormous problem that creates.

LadyKulvax wrote:They think near parity to Outlander bumps Malgus up enormously. Not realising the enormous problem that creates.

Such as?

Malgus is a Sith.

Darth Malgus.

Under the shedding limitations methodology, Malgus in Onslaught wouldn't be capped for being a Sith.

Praxis wrote:Under the shedding limitations methodology, Malgus in Onslaught wouldn't be capped for being a Sith.

fair point actually

When has it been claimed Malgus is a near-peer of the Outlander? And why is it bad that he could briefly hold his own against the Outlander?

OT: Malgus handily.

@Praxis

Under the shedding limitations methodology, Malgus in Onslaught wouldn't be capped for being a Sith.

Why would Malgus even be capped for being a Sith? If it's because of Valkorion saying that Darth Jadus is the best Sith his Empire ever produced, that is said in 3631 BBY. Onslaught takes place in 3627 BBY. That's 4 years later. The Outlander experiences massive growth between KotFE and Onslaught. By all indications, Malgus experiences massive growth between The False Emperor and Onslaught.

@Tybalt I'm referring to Maul, Sheev, or whatever Sith with supremacy quotes dating before Onslaught potentially capping Malgus since I'm pretty sure that's what Kulvax was referring to.

@Praxis

@Tybalt I'm referring to Maul, Sheev, or whatever Sith with supremacy quotes dating before Onslaught potentially capping Malgus since I'm pretty sure that's what Kulvax was referring to.

Per LFL policy there is no hierarchy within the C-Canon level, and according to Leland Chee supremacy quotes are subjective.

@Tybalt Right. I don't think you're necessarily disagreeing with me here. Since supremacy quotes are treated as subjective statements by continuity then they would be subject to when they were written, and whoever wrote one wouldn't have knowledge of the future and shouldn't be used to make claims about the future. However, I don't think supremacy quotes should just be chucked out the window because they are subjective if that's what you are saying, and I think Chee agrees with this as well.

@Praxis

@Tybalt Right. I don't think you're necessarily disagreeing with me here. Since supremacy quotes are treated as subjective statements by continuity then they would be subject to when they were written, and whoever wrote one wouldn't have knowledge of the future and shouldn't be used to make claims about the future. However, I don't think supremacy quotes should just be chucked out the window because they are subjective if that's what you are saying, and I think Chee agrees with this as well.

Oh, I wasn't disagreeing with you. In fact you've summed up my thoughts quite nicely.

Malgus

Jadus pre-Onslaught, Malgus post-Onslaught I'm thinking.