Gollum vs Dobby

Round 1: H2H only. Dobby isn't allowed to use magic.

Round 2: All-out, Gollum has the One Ring and Dobby is allowed to use his magic.

Starting distance is 30 feet. Fight takes place right outside the Lars home circa ANH, it's 11AM.

with magic, dobby no diffs. without it, gollum no diffs. thats how i see it. correct me if im wrong tho

Round 1: Gollum. Gollum was strong enough to strangle goblins. 

Round 2: Dobby? He should be able to incapacitate Gollum with some kind of spell. Although depending on the scenario or how you chose to imagine it, Gollum could actually sneak up and bash Dobby on the head and strangle him.   

I'd still lean Dobby, but a solid case could be made for Gollum.

Round 1: Gollum rather easily 

Round 2: Dobby is more impressive with magic than he looks, he should win.

Golum dies in all horribly.

@HellfireUnit wrote:Golum dies in all horribly.

What feats does Dobby have that will allow him to beat Gollum in round 1, let alone give him a horrible death?

Round 1 Gollum wins easily

Round 2 is a tough one. On one hand Dobby has a significant advantage in that he has a varied amount of spells with an amount of power. On the other I don't think he could detect Gollum with the ring on, so its just as possible for Gollum to get close and kill him

@Nute_Chethray wrote:Round 1 Gollum wins easily

Round 2 is a tough one. On one hand Dobby has a significant advantage in that he has a varied amount of spells with an amount of power. On the other I don't think he could detect Gollum with the ring on, so its just as possible for Gollum to get close and kill him

problem is, dobby can teleport tho. both himself AND gollum. i just dont see gollum ever beating him when he can use magic lol

@Latham2000 wrote:

@HellfireUnit wrote:Golum dies in all horribly.

What feats does Dobby have that will allow him to beat Gollum in round 1, let alone give him a horrible death?

not being a filthy malnourished hobbit

@HellfireUnit wrote:

@Latham2000 wrote:

@HellfireUnit wrote:Golum dies in all horribly.

What feats does Dobby have that will allow him to beat Gollum in round 1, let alone give him a horrible death?

not being a filthy malnourished hobbit

That's no feat. Gollum's feats don't lie though.

@lorenzo.r.2nd wrote:

@Nute_Chethray wrote:Round 1 Gollum wins easily

Round 2 is a tough one. On one hand Dobby has a significant advantage in that he has a varied amount of spells with an amount of power. On the other I don't think he could detect Gollum with the ring on, so its just as possible for Gollum to get close and kill him

problem is, dobby can teleport tho. both himself AND gollum. i just dont see gollum ever beating him when he can use magic lol

Well teleporting is useless if he doesn't know where Gollum is