Re: Suspect Showdown (SS) Request Thread

[HellfireUnitLevel Six]

Ah, missed it...

[Shioz]

I would like to debate Plagueis, Yoda, Dooku or Sidious.

[Master AzrongerModerator]

@HellfireUnit Sorry, not interested in a full SS as there's honestly quite little to discuss between these two.

[The EllimistLevel Five]

I'd be willing to rep the Outlander/Vaylin/Arcann if anyone wanted to debate. My responses will be relatively slow though since I go back to school in a few days.

Would you like to debate Outlander vs. Plagueis?

[PraxisModerator | Champion of the Light]

I'd be willing to rep the Outlander/Vaylin/Arcann if anyone wanted to debate. My responses will be relatively slow though since I go back to school in a few days.

Would you like to debate Outlander vs. Plagueis?

No, I don't think the Outlander would win. Also, I have exams coming relatively soon so I probably won't be doing anything high effort for a while.

[PraxisModerator | Champion of the Light]

This is a question regarding SS’s rather than a debate request so I’m not sure if this is the right place, but is there any prospect of having something like a team SS where two teams debate?

[MPModerator | Champion of Darkness]

This is a question regarding SS’s rather than a debate request so I’m not sure if this is the right place, but is there any prospect of having something like a team SS where two teams debate?

I think that's a good idea tbh.

[Master AzrongerModerator]

This is a question regarding SS’s rather than a debate request so I’m not sure if this is the right place, but is there any prospect of having something like a team SS where two teams debate?

I've been thinking of something like that as well

[MPModerator | Champion of Darkness]

I’d like to engage with someone in a mini-debate. Maybe 3 or 4 posts per side, a small word limit but probably no time limit. Just a quick, mid-tier matchup debate. I’m willing to open, and some characters I’m willing to debate for are Eeth Koth, Adi Gallia and Ki-Adi Mundi - I’m even willing to put these guys up against people like the b-team, so Kit Fisto for example.

[MasterCilghalLevel Three]

I’d like to engage with someone in a mini-debate. Maybe 3 or 4 posts per side, a small word limit but probably no time limit. Just a quick, mid-tier matchup debate. I’m willing to open, and some characters I’m willing to debate for are Eeth Koth, Adi Gallia and Ki-Adi Mundi - I’m even willing to put these guys up against people like the b-team, so Kit Fisto for example.

I would be interested in such a debate, although it would have to start after I finish one of the SS i’m in

[IGLevel Four]

I'm interested in a format like the one MP suggested. I'd prefer to debate for the Jedi Exile, Kun, or Kenobi.

[IGLevel Four]

I'd be willing to rep the Outlander/Vaylin/Arcann if anyone wanted to debate. My responses will be relatively slow though since I go back to school in a few days.

Would you be willing to go for any of them vs. Kyp Durron, or maybe Kun?

[PraxisModerator | Champion of the Light]

Also, I have exams coming relatively soon so I probably won't be doing anything high effort for a while.

^

@IdrisianGraecus I might be open to something in a few weeks but as of right now I'm very busy. I'll let you know if I decide to take up your offer though if you are still open to doing it by then.

[PraxisModerator | Champion of the Light]

@IdrisianGraecus actually you know what? Lets do Outlander vs Kun and you can open since by then I won't be busy.

[IGLevel Four]

Okay, that’s cool with me. Can you make the thread & rules, since I’m fairly busy with school and the like?

[PraxisModerator | Champion of the Light]

Yeah sure I'll have it up by tomorrow hopefully.

[IGLevel Four]

Cool, hopefully I can give you a decent debate, sorry if my 14 year old skills (or rather lack thereof) are rather lacking.

[PraxisModerator | Champion of the Light]

Cool, hopefully I can give you a decent debate, sorry if my 14 year old skills (or rather lack thereof) are rather lacking.

This is my first formal debate so its anybody's game

[King JokerLevel One]

Cool, hopefully I can give you a decent debate, sorry if my 14 year old skills (or rather lack thereof) are rather lacking.

You'll probably do better than I did when I was fourteen, who conceded after the first counter-post was made.

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

Interested in repping Ahsoka (TCW and/or Rebels), Kanan, Vader, Mace, the Outlander, or Vaylin. Can do canon or legends for Ahsoka, Mace and Vader.

[King JokerLevel One]

Where do you rank Kanan, @BreakofDawn?

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

Assuming we’re talking canon, seasons 1 and 2 I’d say he’d be a tier 4 or 5 on Giliard’s scale. By season 3...eh, maybe a 6 or low 7. He’s difficult to quantify without a specific character in mind to compare him to. I’d say at his peak he’d still lose hard to the likes of Vader, but I think he could give a lot of mid tier Force users, including Rebels Ahsoka, a good fight.

[DarthAnt66Moderator]

I think he could give a lot of mid tier Force users, including Rebels Ahsoka, a good fight.

[DarthAnt66Moderator]

@King Joker right now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LsA84bXrBZw&t=1m03s

[BreakofDawnLevel Seven]

I think he could give a lot of mid tier Force users, including Rebels Ahsoka, a good fight.

Not sure what’s bad about that? She’d win everytime of course, but he’d make her work for it. Or is it the mid tier for Ahsoka bit, whereby mid tier is pretty broad and there are only 2-3 tiers above it in my mind?

[Sponsored content]